Chain lube: Wet or dry?

A mountain bike chain is prone to rust; even the mildest of watery conditions can bring about that familiar (to us) mucky brown appearance.

The steel used for the chain is, of course, prone to rust in even the mildest of watery conditions and brine is a much more aggressive agent of corrosion. Chain lube, besides providing a lubricating film between sliding surfaces, might be expected to coat them and thereby hinder the corrosion process. Which does a better job: wet or dry lube?

There are, of course, various wet and dry lubes of differing composition and, presumably, effectiveness. For the purposes of comparison we applied Muc-Off wet lube and Squirt dry lube to two chains prior to riding in especially challenging conditions. The former is the kind of thick, slow-flowing stuff that sticks to everything and might be expected to keep salt water at bay; the latter is a water-soluble dry lube with a fine reputation.

We ran two chains for a short period of time, one lubed with dry wax and the other with a wet lube. The results were eye-opening.

The rollers of the dry lube-treated chain have plenty of visible surface rust on an otherwise shiny surface where no lube remains, while the sideplates appear unaffected by corrosion. Contrastingly, the wet lube-treated chain has surface rust on the outside of the plates while the rollers appear to be oily and dirty if relatively rust-free.

Importantly, both chains have stiff links, those of the dry lubed chain being less obvious  and cannot articulate to the same degree between sprocket and chainwheel. However, the dry-lubed chain ran much more smoothly afterwards with no “gritty” feel and even without the further application of lube soon freed off. The wet-lubed chain felt awful and needed a good clean before it would run smoothly.

The wax contained in the dry lube made a more effective barrier to corrosion than the oil of the wet lube. Although the sideplates of the wet lubed chain retained some oil coverage, they rusted slightly. Those of the dry-lubed chain did not.

This test also showed that the wet lube, as generally believed, attracted and held grit. It also failed to prevent rust attacking the inside surfaces of the chain, the stiff links indicating that they have begun to corrode despite the fact that the chain visibly retains a film of oil. The dry lube did not attract grit to anything like the same degree, meaning that a new application of lube is all that is needed to get it running nicely again.

So, for severe winter use a dry lube - and this one on particular – not only keeps the chain running more smoothly but staves off corrosion and, since it does not attract abrasive grit, should ensure a longer service life for chain and sprockets.

We’ll conduct another deeper into the winter. What sort of chain oil/lube do you currently use, and recommend?

This article first appeared on RoadCyclingUK.com.

  1. Marc

    We only sell the dry lube, as our shop is by the sea, we find the sand in wet lube not only destroys the running gear it turns everything black and nasty. Yes you have to use it a bit more often, but that is far out weighed by the extra longevity of the drive-chain.

  2. Conrad/sadoldsamurai

    Hi,
    As a rider in the wet (always) and acidic muddy Cheviots..(lots of peat..) I have tried dry lube, cheap spray on chain grease and wet lube.
    Given that I now clean the chain properly after each ride, and dry it using WD40 which I dry off before relubing, wet lube definitely does it for me..
    It’s a year and a half since
    a) started using wet lube,
    b) put on the new chain
    c) and that was because I broke 3 chains in as many weeks..and I haven’t changed the chain since..

  3. James

    Been using this through this year’s harsh Yorkshire winter. Superb product.

    Recently tested it by degreasing the chain after four or five rides in the mud. At this stage, an oil based lube would turn the degreaser black and black grit would drop to the bottom of the chain bath.

    With Squirt I was amazed to see the degreaser remain almost clear.

    Great stuff.

  4. Kayleigh

    Every weekend i used to visit this web page, for the reason that i want enjoyment, as this this web site conations truly fastidious funny
    material too.

X

Also in Maintenance

Trek suspension setup calculator

Read More